Wednesday, 12 March 2014

Sourdough Starters

Nancy and Chad
I baked bread occasionally before I moved to the US, but I started in earnest about five years ago when I bought a copy of Peter Reinhart's Bread Baker's Apprentice and some friends gave me baking stone as a birthday present.  I made many recipes from that book over the next few years, gradually gaining a better understanding of the process and becoming more comfortable manipulating and fermenting the dough.  I bought Tartine Bread on the suggestion of a friend, and although I have some criticisms of the book as a whole, the techniques laid out in the core chapter improved my bread tremendously.  But I think I learnt the most from picking up Nancy Silverton's book.  Even though it can be frustrating in many ways (people complain that the recipes weren't sufficiently adapted for home bakers), I think any intermediate to advanced baker could pick up a lot from reading it through carefully and trying to bake her breads.
 
Most bread I bake these days is leavened by a sourdough starter. I have two that I bake with fairly regularly: Chad, which I keep at 100% hydration (i.e. with an equal amount of water and flour) and feed with a 50/50 blend of bread and wholewheat flour; and Nancy, which I keep at 140% hydration (i.e. with 40% more water than flour) and feed solely with bread flour. Both starters are named after the bakers whose recipes I use them in: Chad Robertson from Tartine and Nancy Silverton, formerly from La Brea. 
 
In fact, Chad has a bit of a history.  It is the son of Peter, the first starter I made using the instructions in Peter Reinhart's book.  As I remember, it involved a series of feedings and discards over about a week, with some pineapple juice added at the start, probably to lower the pH and increase available sugars. 
 
I baked with Peter a few times, never with any great success (the starter was fine, I just wasn't a good baker then), and eventually gave some to a friend who kept it going and transformed it into the Tartine starter, passing on discards to several other bakers along the way.  It makes me happy to think that several people in Chicago are using off-shoots of that original starter.  Meanwhile I neglected and eventually threw out Peter. A couple of months later, when I started baking again, I got some back from my friend and it was at that point that she recommended the Tartine book.  I picked up a copy of the book, christened my new starter Chad, and kept it at the same proportions my friend had it at. 
 
I was very happy with the Tartine loaf, and its still the bread I bake most frequently (I'll have a separate post up about it shortly).  But as my interest in baking continued to grow, I wanted to try some other kinds of dough, so I picked up a book that had been recommended to me by a professional baker some time ago: Nancy Silverton's Breads of La Brea Bakery.  Rather than converting Chad to her proportions, I decided to make a new starter with her instructions.  This involved harvesting yeast from the skins of grapes, by immersing the fruit in the mixed flour and water using a cheesecloth bag.  Silverton's process is famously wasteful, require large amounts of flour and regular feedings and discards.  I don't know that I would recommend it, but Nancy made some lovely bread when I first started using it.  It may be pure suggestion, but the starter and bread both seemed to have an almost wine-like aroma to them.
 
These days I use Chad more than Nancy, but I keep Chad in the fridge between bakes, where as Nancy lives out on the counter.  This is partly because I have been trying to bring Nancy back from a 6+ month neglect.  It worked to some extent---the starter is active again---but I haven't had time to get back to a regular cycle of feedings and bakes yet, so it is not at its best.  What's more, with the starter out on the counter its much more important to feed it regularly so that the bacterial population doesn't get out of control, and I often forget or simply don't have time to do this.
 
Chad lives in the fridge, but I pull it out to bake with at least 2 or 3 times a week.  As a result it remains very active, and I don't need to feed it more than once before baking.  At any rate, I like the bread it produces and it rises without difficulty.  I've been wondering lately if I couldn't improve it further by taking Chad out of the fridge and feeding it regularly on the counter.
 
I should say a little bit about the differences between the starters.  My understanding here is fairly limited, but here's what I know.  Drier starters like Chad (100% hydration---so not that dry!) tend to end up with a higher proportion of acetic acid than lactic acid; the drier condition also favour yeast over bacteria, so the resulting bread is often less tangy and sour.  This is especially true of the Tartine loaf, which uses a relatively small proportion of young starter.  Wetter starters like Nancy favour the growth of lactobacillus and other souring bacteria, and often produce a higher proportion of lactic acid.  This is actually a smoother, more pleasant tasting acid than acetic (for brewers, its the difference between a crisp sour berlinerweisse, and a vinegary one), and perhaps accounts for the wine-like aromas I associate with Nancy.  The resulting bread is often more tangy and sour, both because of the higher bacterial population of the starter and because you tend to use more of it to leaven the dough since the yeast numbers are lower (at least, I think that's why---you can find out more about these things by finding posts from Debra Wink on The Fresh Loaf).
 
Since conditions in wetter starters tend to favour bacteria, you have to keep up with regular feedings to keep their numbers in check, especially if baking in a hotter climate.  The initial feeding favours yeast slightly over bacteria, so by feeding regularly you give the yeast an advantage.  This is very important if you are trying to rescue a starter that has been neglected or just become too sour over time.  Regular feedings and discards will help to change the population back to something that will produce a pleasant loaf.

One more note on high hydration starters: they make excellent pancake batter!  The resulting pancakes are fluffy, light, and tangy. Nancy Silverton includes a recipe in her book for use with her starter: 2.2 lbs starter, 1 tsp baking powder, 1/2 tsp baking soda, 1/2 tsp salt, 2 eggs. 2 tbsp maple syrup; whisk together and cook.  Easy.  But I'm sure you could make also use a 100% hydration starter if you added more liquid to the batter (although the resulting pancakes might be less tangy).

Thursday, 6 March 2014

Kimchi


Kimchi
As well a brewing beer, I also enjoy making various fermented foods.  I'll do a post about sourdough bread soon, but I also like ferment and pickle vegetables, and make jams and other preserves.

Recently J and I have made a few batches of kimchi: a
Korean staple of sour, spicy, fermented cabbage and other vegetables.  For our most recent batch we made a special trip up to a Korean supermarket on the other side of Chicago: Joong Boo near the Belmont Blue Line stop.  (We also stopped in at The Beer Temple and the Half Acre tap room.)  This was our first visit, and it was exciting to find such a wide array of Korean ingredients, all much cheaper than the things we'd been purchasing online.  Specific to kimchi, we got some hot pepper flakes, anchovy sauce, and fermented salted shrimp.  This last is very pungent and can easily stink out your whole fridge if your not careful.  Ours is safely stashed in a sealed plastic bag, which seems to have done the trick.

Ingredients
In the past we've used David Chang's recipe, which turned out rather well.  The sauce maintained its thickness, whereas our more recent attempts have ended up with a lot more juice at the end of fermentation.  I wonder if this isn't in part because he adds more sugar, which absorbs the water that continues to be drawn out of the cabbage over the course of fermentation.  Regardless, we wanted to try a more traditional recipe, so the last few times we amalgamated this recipe with things we picked up from Maangchi's excellent videos.

Salted Cabbage
The process is fairly simple (again, see this for proper step-by-step instructions) and doesn't take too long if you have two people.  First you have to separate the cabbage leaves out slightly,  salt them for a few hours to draw out some water.  Last time we did this in brine, but this week I just added salt to the cabbage directly and let it sit for a few hours.

Ingredients for paste
While the salt drew out moisture from the cabbage, we chopped up the onion, garlic, ginger, chillies, and asian pear, and blended them all together to make a rough,spicy paste.  The pear was fairly firm with a slightly mealy texture and a sweet but almost savoury taste.  I assume its mainly there to add a bit of sweetness in the final product, as this recipe uses no sugar at all (we added a little later on though, following Maangchi's technique).

Sweet rice porridge
After this, J made a porridge out of water, sweet rice flour, and sugar, heating it until we saw occasional bubbles break the surface, and then stirring it gently until it turned slightly translucent.  She cooled this in the sink while I chopped up the rest of the vegetables and gathered them all together in one bowl.  Last time we just used daikon, carrot, mustard greens, and spring onion, but this time we had proper Korean radish and Asian chives from the store.

Vegetables, fish, and porridge
At this point, we added a generous cup of the deep-red hot-pepper flakes to the porridge, along with a quarter cup of anchovy sauce and a scant two teaspoons of fermented shrimp.  This is far less than the recipe called for (although in line with Chang's version).  I was cautious because I've been a vegetarian all my life, and while I'm OK with trying to use these products in a recipe like this, the flavours are often too much for me; and this shrimp smelt very fishy.

Stuffing the cabbage
Finally, we stirred the cool porridge mixture in with the vegetables, mixed it all together, and donned rubber gloves to stuff the washed cabbage.  When each piece was done, I wrapped it over itself and pushed it down into a mason jar (making an enormous mess in the process).  With the jars a little over 3/4 full, we closed them up and wiped down the sides.  One jar was left out for 24 hours to encourage a quicker fermentation, but the others will sit in the fridge for a few weeks before we touch them to build their sour, fizzy, flavour.  Luckily we still have some of our last batch left in the fridge to eat while we wait.

All in all, a very easy fermentation, and well worth the effort.  I think one large jar of kimchi cost about $10 at the store, so this is certainly more than we could ever afford if we were buying it.  Besides, it makes for a really quick and easy week night (or post-pub) meal, along with a bowl of short grain rice and some
tofu.  Yum.


Wednesday, 5 March 2014

Golden Bitters

Golden Bitter with Amarillo
Only seems right that the first beers I post here are a pair of bitters.  These are the kind of pale English beers I really love.  Less than 4% ABV, gentle but definite hop aroma and flavour, firm bitterness, dry and drinkable.  Both are directly inspired by a recipe that Kristen England posted on the Northern Brewer forum.

A quick digression on the man himself. He is head brewer at Bent Brewstillery (formerly at Pour Decisions, which had some really interesting looking beers that seem to have been lost in the merger with this new company), and at one point at least was supposed to be working on a book about session beer. I first came across him in episodes of Brewing TV and videos on the Northern Brewer blog.  He seemed fairly opinionated, but as I learnt more about brewing and came back to those episodes I realized he really knew his stuff. In fact, between his Let's Brew posts with Ron Pattinson on Shut Up About Barclay Perkins, and his Gratzer, Gose, and Berliner Weisse recipes in Brewing with Wheat, I've probably brewed more recipes written by him than anyone other brewer.

In the post in question England describes the two kinds of bitter he enjoys: "the ones that are more caramel and less hop and the ones that are lighter and more hopped".  I enjoy both, but definitely prefer the latter, and feel like its the kind of English beer that isn't always well represented in the US. I had a couple of great ones when I went home to England this summer.  Stand-outs included a pint of Salopian's Shropshire Gold  at my favourite pub in Liverpool, The Ship and Mitre; and the Summer Ale made on premises at another lovely Liverpool pub, The Baltic Fleet.   England's recipe is based on a beer I've never (knowingly) tried: Crouch Vale's Brewers Gold.

The recipe couldn't be simpler: 100% lager malt, and a large dose of hops at 15 minutes left in the boil.  Here's the original version with his notes:

Crouch Vale Brewers Gold
Gravity (OG) 1.040 (measured)
Gravity (FG) 1.010 (measured)
ABV 4.03% (measured)
Apparent attenuation 74.38% (measured)
Real attenuation 61.7% (measured)
IBU 35 
SRM 2.2 (measured)
EBC 5.4

5gal (19L)
Grist
English lager malt 8lb (3.65kg)

Mash: 151F x 60min

Boil: 90min

Hops
3.5oz Brewers Gold - 7.9% - 15min

Yeast: 
Ferment at 63F
1) WLP022 Essex or 2) WLP013/ Wy1028

Notes:
I would suggest that you don't make any changes to start. When I want it more 'bittery' I'll swap out some base malt for some #2 invert or 75L crystal. The pils malt is 100% mandatory and if you can't get UK pils use the Belgian stuff. If you can't find the Belgian stuff then use Optic or Halcyon NOT Maris Otter or Golden Promise. ANY hop will work for this recipe but I would seriously just stick with one variety. Amarillo is actually VERY nice. FYI - The lower AA% hops lend more aroma and flavor ONLY b/c you have to add more of them to get the bitterness.

I've brewed this three times now.  In every case, I subbed a Belgian pilsner for the lager malt.  For hops, I used Amarillo the first and second time, and East Kent Goldings on my last attempt.  The two versions posted here were fermented with Wyeast London Ale (1028), which gives them a crisp, minerally finish; my first version used West Yorkshire (1469).

Golden Bitter with EKG
Both are a beautiful hazy gold, with a good head on pouring that sticks around as a thin layer for as long as it takes me to drink the beer.  Probably has something to do with all the protein from the pilsner malt, and perhaps the large quantities of hops too.  I think they might drop bright with a week in the fridge, but I get through them so quick they don't have a chance.  I aimed for under 2 volumes carbonation: this worked perfectly in the EKG version, but this time the Amarillo one didn't quite carbonate enough and tastes a little thin.

The Amarillo version is surprisingly floral.  I think of Amarillo as being a citrusy hop like Cascade, but for some reason in this beer it gives a soft, flowery aroma and flavour that is a long way from the sharper grapefruit notes I associate with it.  (After another taste, it actually has a very soft grapefruit bitterness, pith and peel in the background). The EKG version has a gentle but firm bitterness, and a flavour that reminds me of preserved oranges, almost like marmalade but not as assertive, and wonderful tea-like tannins that build gradually as you drink it. This might be because you have to use so much EKG to get the right levels of IBUs (almost double the amount of Amarillo), and is perhaps another reason it seems less thin than the Amarillo version.

In both cases, the hop flavour and aroma is relatively restrained given the quantities used (stronger with the Amarillo), perhaps because I'm using older hops that I wanted to use up (properly stored in vacuum-sealed bags in the freezer, of course). In any case, its a flavour profile I really enjoy.  The final beer is balanced and subtle, with a definite bitterness that makes me want to drink pint after pint.  The EKG version has disappeared very quickly, and the Amarillo won't last much longer.


Tuesday, 4 March 2014

Useful Brewing Resources

This post will be a list of resources I've found useful in learning to brew better beer.  It is intended to be more personal than comprehensive.  Hopefully it will be updated regularly!


[Work in Progress!]

Process and Technique

 

Brew in a Bag


  • This forum is where I learnt how to brew in this way.  I started off using an earlier version of their calculator, then switched to BeerSmith before the new one was released, and I haven't had time to play with the new version.  But I would bet its the best BIAB brew software available.
  • Beersmith podcast with Pat Hollingdale, one of the people behind the above forum.
  • Brewing TV episode on BIAB.

Blending

  • There’s an interesting talk by Matt Brynildson from Firestone Walker about blending beers in the middle of this episode of the Session.
  • Interviews with Lauren and Eric Salazar from New Belgium: particularly good on their sour beers.  They also discuss it together in this interview from Cellarmanship.
     

Kinds of Beer

 

Sour, Farmhouse, and Wild Brewing

Chad Yakobson


This guy is very knowledgeable about brettanomyces and wild brewing; and what's more, he seems to be equally generous with his time and knowledge.  His website has lots of useful data regarding brewing with brettanomyces, including a copy of his dissertation, Pure Culture Fermentation Characteristics of Brettanomyces Yeast Species and Their Use in the Brewing Industry.  This set of slides provides a nice summary of some of the results in the dissertation, and is relatively easy to decipher even if you do not have a background in brewing science (I certainly don't).
 
His various interviews and talks are also worth tracking down.  The Sunday Session interview he did is full of useful information about brewing with brettanomyces, and he talks a bit about the beers he's been brewing at his new project: Crooked Stave.  The videos of his presentation at Music City Brew Off contain still more helpful advice.  I've embedded the first one on the right.
 
A few other links worth checking out:


The Mad Fermentationist


Another knowledgeable and generous home-brewer.  His website is a wonderful resource: a good source for brewing information and general inspiration when it comes to all kinds of fermentations, but particularly for sour beer.  I recommend this post about brewing sour beers at home.  But it will soon be superseded by his book, which I'm very excited about.  He posts regularly on the HBT Lambic & Wild Brewing forum as Oldsock, and I've learnt a lot from reading his posts.  He has also done a number of interviews with Basic Brewing Radio.  Here are direct audio links to interviews on brewing saisons, Berliner Weisse, off-beat yeast, and solera brewing (1 and 2).  He shows up in a few other episodes as well, and also on a few episodes of the BeerSmith podcast.  Finally, he is also associated with Modern Times Beer.
 
 

Vinnie Cilurzo


I learnt a great deal from Vinnie's interviews and presentations when I started brewing sour beers.  Here's a few of the best:
  • Vinnie discusses his belgian-style beers on the Sunday Session.
  • Another Sunday Session interview which deals explicitly with the way Russian River ferments their sour beers.
  • This episode of the Sunday Session includes a presentation by Vinnie.  I listened to this several times before brewing my first sour beers.
  • I've embedded an interview by More Beer in which Vinnie discusses sour beers.  This is part four of a longer interview.
 

Brewing Network


I learnt a lot from these podcasts when I first started brewing, particularly Brew Strong and Can You Brew It (my interest in both shows has dwindled these days).  The Sunday Session also has some great interviews, but I usually fast forward through the rest of it.  Here are some personal favourites:
  • Mike Mraz tackles Jolly Pumpkin's Bam Biere and Dark Dawn for CYBI.  The interviews with Ron Jeffries are great---yet another knowledagble and generous brewer!  I particularly recommend the Bam Biere episode for people looking to brew an easy first sour beer.
  • Great interview with the guys from Jester King Brewery.  Among other things, they discuss blending old sour beer with fresh hoppy beer.  Expect a post on this soon!
  • Dave Marliave from Flat Tail Brewing discusses some interesting techniques for sour beers (episode degenerates somewhat mid-interview, but then recovers).  I started a topic on HBT about this.
  • Not really about sours, but this episode with Shea Comfort is one of the best interviews they've done.  Just full of information.  Topics discussed include using wine yeast in fermentation, and using oak in beer.
  • There are many more worth listening to. 


BeerSmith Podcast

 
Another informative brewing podcast.  Lots of great episodes on a variety of topics, but for sour and wild brewing I recommend the following:
 

Message Boards


I'm constantly impressed by how friendly and helpful home brew message boards are.  Here are some relevant resources:
  • Lambic & Wild Brewing forum on HomeBrewTalk.  I post under the username "metic".
  • The Burgundian Babble Belt homebrew board seems fairly quiet these days, but the archives are all available and worth reading through.  In some ways, its part of the story of people discovering and experimenting with brett-only fermentations.  You can find early posts by Chad Yakobson of Crooked Stave, Al Buck of East Coast Yeast, and Michael Tonsemeire (The Mad Fermentationist).  There are also transcripts of tasting sessions and swaps with people like Peter Bouckaert from New Belgium, and Tomme Arthur from Lost Abbey. 


Miscellaneous Information and Inspiration

  • Sour Beer episode from Brewing TV.  This was what made me start exploring sour beers!
  • An interview with one of my favourite brewers and beer writers, Yvan de Baets, along with his brewing partner Bernard Leboucq, both from Brasserie De La Senne.
  • An interview with Ron Jeffries of Jolly Pumpkin.
  • Basic Brewing Radio interview with Cantillon's Jean van Roy (direct audio).  Particularly interesting because he discusses some of the difficulties homebrewers might have in adapting Cantillon's cooling and inoculation methods.



Session Beer


Not sure how I feel about the name, but I suppose it fits the kind of beers I grew up drinking in the U.K. and still love to brew.
 

 


 

Monday, 3 March 2014

A Typical Brew Day

This post documents a typical brew day.  Every brewer has their own process, shaped in various ways by their work-space, equipment, budget, and so on.  My aim here is to give you a sense of how the beers posted on this blog are brewed, and to show how the brew day routine I've settled on fits with my own constraints and aims in brewing.  This is not supposed to be a how-to guide!

BeerSmith Equipment Profile

Recipe Formulation


I use BeerSmith 2 to formulate my recipes.  My standard Equipment Profile is for a 3 gallon batch---or rather, it gives me enough beer to take a hydrometer reading post-primary fermentation and also fill a 3 gallon Better Bottle completely if I transfer to secondary.  I first formulated this profile to minimize oxidation in sour beers that would be sitting in a carboy for many months, but I now use it for almost all beers.

My mash efficiency is typically between 75-80%, but because of the way BeerSmith works out overall efficiency my Brewhouse number is only 53%.  I typically get within a few points of my target O.G., but there is definitely room for improvement here: sometimes I am off by as much as 4 or 5 points, and I need to work out when this happens and why.

Propagating the Yeast


For the past year and a half, I've banked every yeast strain I've used on slants.  Even though I've never had an infection, I am convinced that my aseptic technique is terrible and I'm amazed every time it works out.  A week before brew day, I take a few cells from a slant and begin to grow them up in 10ml of wort.  From here I step them up through a series of starters on my stir-plate: usually 50ml, ~500ml, and then 1-1.5l.  The first beer I pitch into usually has a low O.G. and is never something I really care about; essentially its another extra-large starter.  I have no way of accurately counting pitching rates, so there is a lot of guess work involved in all of this.

Most of the time, I plan a series of beers for a particular pitch of yeast.  Almost all the strains I use regularly are excellent top-croppers:  Wyeast West Yorkshire (1469), London Ale III (1318), Ardennes (3522), Trappist High Gravity (3787).  I harvest all of these directly from the fermenter during active fermentation, but I also wash other strains collected after fermentation is over: in particular, Wyeast French Saison (3711), Lallemand Belle Saison, and any brett strain used for primary fermentation.  There are a few other strains that I use less frequently, and I've recently added some new ones from The Yeast Bay that I'm excited to try out.  I also keep a few dry packets of Nottingham, US-05, and Belle Saison around in case something goes wrong with a starter.  (I have a collection of souring organisms and wild yeast in gallon jugs, but they deserve a separate post.)

Milling the Grain


I purchase grain in bulk through group buys organized by Chicago Home Brewers Group.  Usually I have a Belgian or German pilsner malt, a British base malt, and standard American two-row on hand at all times.  I also buy some adjuncts such as wheat or rye in bulk (usually half sacks), as well as specialty grains like Vienna or Munich.  Once I bought a half sack of Crystal, but most of it is still unused 6 months later.

Corona Grain Mill
I mill all my grain by hand using a Corona Mill.  This is a good example of a place where my process fits the kind of beers I tend to brew.  Since I'm typically doing a 3 gallon batch, and aiming for a low gravity beer, cranking the grist out by hand isn't too difficult; and since I'm doing BIAB, I don't have to worry about stuck sparges caused by milling too finely.  So in a sense the Corona is limiting: milling the grist for high gravity beers is annoying, as is brewing more than 3 gallons at a time.  But, for the most part, I'm not very interested in brewing big beers; and I brew frequently enough that 3 gallons is usually plenty.  (I do sometimes wish that I could brew larger quantities of sour beer, since they take so long to age and tie up fermenters.)

Some people make modifications to improve their mills, but I haven't changed mine at all.  I condition the grain before milling: spraying it with water from a spray bottle, mixing the grain up to make sure the water is absorbed evenly.  This preserves the husks, and slightly reduces the amount of flour in the grist; but even using this technique I still end up with a fair bit of flour, and I try to accommodate this by other steps in my process.

The Mash


BIAB Mash
I do full volume, single-vessel Brew in a Bag.  I still use the 36-quart pot I used for my four or five extract batches.  Eventually I would like to upgrade to something larger, ideally with a ball-valve and thermometer; but that may take a while given my budget.  When I first moved to BIAB, I used paint-strainer bags, and then cheap mesh bags from my LHBS.  Last year I upgraded to a custom-made bag from wilserbrewer on HBT, and I've been very happy with it so far.  My earlier bags all split at the seams, even after I reinforced them with back-stitches; this one has held up well so far.  The stick is a wooden paint-stirrer with volumes marked onto it. I also place a stainless-steel steamer underneath the bag to avoid scorching the grain when I apply heat to the wort.  

I usually measure out the full volume of water from the tap the night before brewing, add half a campden tablet, and let it sit until the next day.  This deals with any chlorine or chloramines in the water.  I also usually add 3-4 ml of lactic acid for pale beers.  Since I don't have anyway way of testing my mash pH, I don't know if this makes any difference.  (I would like to buy a pH meter, but again its currently outside my budget.)  Sometimes I add 1/4 to 1/2 tsp of gypsum or calcium chloride, based on the kind of beer I am brewing; but again, this is mainly habit and I haven't really paid attention to any difference it might make in the final product.  Sometime soon I will sit down with the copy of Water I got this Christmas and work out something more informed here.

Insulated Kettle
 I typically mash for ~90 minutes.  Sometimes I perform step-mashes, but usually I do a single-infusion mash and leave it undisturbed for the full time.  I insulate my kettle with an old vinyl exercise mat that I cut up to fit around it: one piece for the sides, and one piece for the top.  I also put an old sleeping bag on top of this.  With this insulation, my mash temperature usually only drops by 1-2 °F over the course of 90 minutes.  Occasionally I take the kettle off the stove while I mash, but after suffering a hernia (no doubt in part related to lifting this full kettle up and down!) I'm now much more cautious about moving it, and often leave it wrapped-up on the stove-top.

Draining the Bag
After 90 minutes is up, I raise the temperature of the wort to 168 °F, then immediately remove the bag and place it on an oven-rack above the kettle to allow the wort to drain.  At first I weigh the bag down with any heavy objects that are nearby; after a few minutes, I squeeze it by hand to extract still more wort.  I have never noticed any astringent off-flavours in the final beer that might be related to squeezing the grain, but perhaps someone with a better palette would.

Since the Corona produces a fair bit of flour in the grist, and since I am doing BIAB and do not recirculate, I often have a very cloudy wort at this point.

The Boil


While the bag is draining, I continue to heat the wort up to a boil.  I typically boil for 90 minutes, in part to encourage proteins to coagulate so that I end up with a clear beer (this is one of the step I take to accommodate the fact that I use a Corona and BIAB), and in part because I am often using pilsner malt and want to avoid DMS in the final beer.  I also skim some of the scum that collects as the wort reaches a boil so that it is not in the boil for the whole time.

Kettle Additions
Kettle additions are all measured out pre-boil.  I've already mentioned the lactic acid added to the mash-water.  I also add 1/2 tab of whirlfloc when there is 10 minutes left in the boil.  This is to encourage a good cold break, and is yet another step I take to ensure clear beer given the fact that I start the boil with a fairly cloudy wort.  It seems to work, as I get a good cold break and my final beer is clear.  When I do not add whirlfloc. the beer is very murky.

While the boil is going, I fill the fermenter with 3 gallons of star-san solution, and soak my wort-chiller, tubing, racking cane, etc for the last 15 minutes of the boil.  I then remove all of this to another bucket along with most of the star-san, seal the bucket up, and give it a good shake to make sure all the surfaces are coated with star-san bubbles.  Sometimes I just add my wort-chiller to the kettle for the last 15-20 minutes of the boil.

Cooling the Wort

Post-Boil


After the boil is over, I put my wort-chiller into the kettle and fill the sink with cold water.  If I am not performing a hop-stand, I immediately begin to circulate cold-water through the chiller using a cheap sump-pump.  I collect the hot water that comes out the other end in a large tub, add oxy-clean, and use it to soak any empty bottles I have at the time.

One great thing about the cold Chicago winters is the low ground-water temperatures we get for half of the year.  These, combined with the fact that I stir the wort every few minutes, mean that I often reach pitching temperature ( ~64°F) in 20-25 minutes (and get down to 90°F in about 10 minutes).  In the summer, when the water is warmer, everything takes longer and I have to add a bag of ice to get the wort down the final 20°F.

When I'm not stirring the wort, I leave the lid propped on top of the kettle.  One improvement I would like to make here is to recirculate the wort with a pump rather than stirring it by hand.  This would result in faster cooling times, and minimize the risk of infection since I wouldn't have to remove the lid (I've never had one so far, but I do worry about it).  But it would require a ball-valve on my kettle, and a pump that could withstand high-temperatures, and once again both are currently outside my budget.
Whirlpool

Once the wort is cool, I take one more step to ensure clear beer: a whirlpool.  I stir the wort in the kettle for a minute or so until a steady whirlpool forms, put the lid back on, and let it sit for between 30-45 minutes.  Even with this step I still end up leaving a fair bit of wort in the kettle, because I end up with a lot of cold-break and it doesn't form a nice cone post-whirlpool like the hops do.

I often reuse this left-over wort.  First I strain it to remove as much of the hops and cold-break material as I can, then leave it to settle for an hour or two, before pouring off the clear wort that results.  This either goes in the fridge to reboil for a starter in the next week, or gets canned in my pressure cooker for future use.

At this point I transfer the wort to a fermenter using an auto-siphon. I do transfer some of the break material across to the fermenter, but for the most part I try to make sure I am transferring clear wort.

Oxygenating Wort
Once the wort has been transferred, I oxygenate it.  Sometimes I do this by transferring the wort through a small piece of racking-cane with a hole in it, exploiting the venturi effect.  About a year ago I bought an oxygenation kit, and I use this when I brewing something with an O.G. above 1.050, or when I want to make sure I end up with a very dry beer.

Fermentation


Finally, I pitch the yeast.  If I am using a new pack of commercial yeast that is relatively fresh, I will pitch it directly.  If the yeast is older, or if I am growing it up from a slant, I will make a series of starters to grow up sufficient quantity of cells.  There is always some guess-work involved here, as I have no reliable way to do cell-counts.  As I said above, I like to top-crop yeast during active fermentation, and if I am brewing frequently enough I will re-pitch this within a couple of days.
Fermentation Chamber

Primary fermentation takes place in my temperature-controlled fermentation chamber.  It is made from a cheap second-hand fridge, extended with an insulated wooden collar.  The temperature is controlled by an aquarium temperature controller purchased from Ebay and wired using instructions on HBT.  A friend helped me build it all, and while its not the most sturdy or well-insulated chamber, it can hold ale fermentation temperatures just fine.  I've also fermented some kolsch-style beers at as low as 55°F in there.

Most of the time my primary fermentation vessel is a bucket.  I like using them because it is easy to top-crop yeasts, and because I can ferment enough wort to fill a 3 gallon Better Bottle post-fermentation.  Sometimes I leave the lid cracked for an open fermentation, and sometimes I ferment directly in a Better Bottle, using fermcap to prevent overflow.

Sours and other wild beers
I don't always bother transferring to secondary, but when I do it is usually in a 3 gallon Better Bottle.  I have ~10 of these at the moment, and I'll probably get more. Sometimes I transfer so that I can cycle other beers through my buckets and crop the resulting yeast, and sometimes I transfer for long term aging.  I have a separate closet (without temperature control) where I store my sours.  I worry about them in the high temperatures of the Chicago summer, but I don't know what to do about it.

Bottling

I bottle all my beers.  I would love to keg, but once again I don't have space in my budget at the moment.  This does fit with the rest of my process though: I am unlikely to buy new equipment to allow me to brew larger batches until I can do some kegging, as I bottle fairly frequently and doing 5 or 10 gallon batches would be a nuisance.

I have two sets of equipment for this: one for regular beers, and one for sour beers or beers fermented with brettanomyces.  One recent step I added to my process is adding BioFine Clear to my pale beers at bottling.  This is yet another measure to ensure I have crystal clear beer, and it generally works well after a few weeks in the bottle.

Final Thoughts

So, there you have it.  As I said, the whole process makes sense to me given my constraints and my aims, and its getting to the point where I feel like any change would have to be quite major. 

Saturday, 1 March 2014

What’s Fermenting?

A list of beers currently fermenting.  See also the Projects page, which is a better overview of the site.

I’ll try to keep this up to date.  If you want to understand my fermenter naming system, the main thing to know is that the second letter indicates whether the fermenter has had brett and/or LAB in it: “C” means clean, “B” means brett.  My “house culture” started with Jolly Pumpkin dregs, and has since had more dregs, a bunch of brett strains, and ECY20 added to it.  The lactobacillus started as a pack of Wyeast Berliner Weisse blend (3191); I’ve kept it going by feeding it apple juice, and there’s a chance there’s some brett from the original blend in there too.

Fermenter Beer Fermenting with… Notes
       
Buckets      
BC1      
BB1      
BM1      
       
Wide-mouth Carboys      
BUB5      
       
3 Gallon      
BC1      
BC2      
BB1 Buckwheat Saison WY3726  Blended with small portion of year old lambic-style beer.
BB2 Second Extraction Saison WY3726  Aging on spent and peaches from pLambic, plus three pounds fresh peaches.
BB3 Second Extraction Brown Ale WY3209 Cherries to be added in secondary
BB4 Arthur’s Remains WY3726 Dregs from Hill Farmstead Arthur pitched with yeast.
BB5 Second Extraction Saison WY3726  Aging on spent raspberries and cherries from Flanders Red
BB6 Sour Red Ale WY1318 To be aged with small portion of 1 year old Flanders Red.
BB7 Keeping Porter WY1469   
BB8 C19th IPA WY1028; WLP645; WLP644   
BB9 Stock Ale WY1318 Added dregs from brett-fermented wit.
BB10 Stingo WY1469   
BB11 Adjunct Sour ECY20  
G1 New Hop Saison WY3726  
G2 Dark Sour WY3522; ECY20  Cut with aged sour
       
5 Gallon      
G1 Aged Hop Saison Wyeast 3726 Blended with one gallon of adjunct sour.
B1 Rye Saison WY3726 Four gallons saison with one gallon no-boil sour.
B2 Adjunct Sour ECY01  
       
6 Gallon      
B1 Pale Sour Ale WY3763; ECY20 In perpetuum
B2 Flanders Red ECY02 In perpetuum
B3 ECY Solera Batch 1 ECY20  In perpetuum
       
Small jugs      
1x1 gallon
1x0.5 gallon
No-boil sour WLP644; WLP645; lacto For blending.
2x0.5 gallon Adjunct Sour ECY01  
1 gallon jug House Culture ECY20; JP dregs; various brett strains.